Take time out and read this transcript of Karan thapar's int with HRD Min Arjun Singh.
The h'ble Union Minister for Human Resource & Development does not know facts and figures made official by the Government of India and its
agencies. He doesnt have a clue at what is going on in the country
Last Night on CNN-IBN at 00:30 hrs on a show called "Devil's Advocate",
Devil's Advocate Karan Thapar investigated Arjun Singh..and this Minister
had no reasons to support his stand on Reservations…Karan Thapar came out
with marvelous statistical data pointing out that out of 27.2% reservation
offered to the backward community, only 16% gets occupied every year in
institutions like IIT's IIM's and many others..rest 11% goes vacant every
year …which means that every year 11% of the seats are not allotted to
anybody..irrespective of generally category students meeting the criteria
of qualifying for the seats…This Minister was dumbfolded with the most
pathetic answer to Karan Thapar's question..His answer was "I DON'T KNOW" &
TO ALMOST ALL THE OTHER QUESTIONS.
-x-
Karan Thapar: Hello and welcome to the Devil's Advocate. As the debate over
the reservations for the OBCs divides the country, we ask - What are the
government's real intentions? That is the critical questions that I shall
put today in an exclusive interview to the Minister for Human Resource
Development Arjun Singh.
Most of the people would accept that steps are necessary to help the OBCs
gain greater access to higher education. The real question is - Why do you
believe that reservations is the best way of doing this?
Arjun Singh: I wouldn't like to say much more on this because these are
decisions that are taken not by individuals alone. And in this case, the
entire Parliament of this country - almost with rare anonymity - has
decided to take this decision.
Karan Thapar: Except that Parliament is not infallible. In the Emergency,
when it amended the Constitution, it was clearly wrong, it had to reverse
its own amendments. So, the question arises - Why does Parliament believe
that the reservation is the right way of helping the OBCs?
Arjun Singh: Nobody is infallible. But Parliament is Supreme and atleast I,
as a Member of Parliament, cannot but accept the supremacy of Parliament.
Karan Thapar: No doubt Parliament is supreme, but the constitutional
amendment that gives you your authorities actually unenabling amendment, it
is not a compulsory requirement. Secondly, the language of the amendment
does not talk about reservations, the language talks about any provision by
law for advancement of socially and educationally backward classes. So, you
could have chosen anything other than reservations, why reservations?
Arjun Singh: Because as I said, that was the 'will and desire of the
Parliament'.
Karan Thapar: Do you personally also, as Minister of Human Resource
Development , believe that reservations is the right and proper way to help
the OBCs?
Arjun Singh: Certainly, that is one of the most important ways to do it.
Karan Thapar: The right way?
Arjun Singh: Also the right way.
Karan Thapar: In which case, lets ask a few basic questions; we are talking
about the reservations for the OBCs in particular. Do you know what
percentage of the Indian population is OBC? Mandal puts it at 52 per cent,
the National Sample Survey Organisation at 32 per cent, the National Family
and Health Survey at 29.8 per cent, which is the correct figure?
Arjun Singh: I think that should be decided by people who are more
knowledgeable. But the point is that the OBCs form a fairly sizeable
percentage of our population.
Karan Thapar: No doubt, but the reason why it is important to know 'what
percentage' they form is that if you are going to have reservations for
them, then you must know what percentage of the population they are,
otherwise you don't know whether they are already adequately catered in
higher educational institutions or not.
Arjun Singh: That is obvious - they are not.
Karan Thapar: Why is it obvious?
Arjun Singh: Obvious because it is something which we all see.
Karan Thapar: Except for the fact that the NSSO, which is a government
appointed body, has actually in its research in 1999 - which is the most
latest research shown - that 23.5 per cent of all university seats are
already with the OBCs. And that is just 8.5 per cent less than what the
NSSO believes is the OBC share of the population. So, for a difference of 8
per cent, would reservations be the right way of making up the difference?
Arjun Singh: I wouldn't like to go behind all this because, as I said,
Parliament has taken a view and it has taken a decision, I am a servant of
Parliament and I will only implement.
Karan Thapar: Absolutely, Parliament has taken a view, I grant it. But what
people question is the simple fact - Is there a need for reservations? If
you don't know what percentage of the country is OBC, and if furthermore,
the NSSO is correct in pointing out that already 23.5 per cent of the
college seats are with the OBC, then you don't have a case in terms of
need.
Arjun Singh: College seats, I don't know.
Karan Thapar: According to the NSSO - which is a government appointed body
- 23.5 per cent of the college seats are already with the OBCs.
Arjun Singh: What do you mean by college seats?
Karan Thapar: University seats, seats of higher education.
Arjun Singh: Well, I don't know I have not come across that far.
Karan Thapar: So, when critics say to you that you don't have a case for
reservation in terms of need, what do you say to them?
Arjun Singh: I have said what I had to say and the point is that that is
not an issue for us to now debate.
Karan Thapar: You mean the chapter is now closed?
Arjun Singh: The decision has been taken.
Karan Thapar: Regardless of whether there is a need or not, the decision is
taken and it is a closed chapter.
Arjun Singh: So far as I can see, it is a closed chapter and that is why I
have to implement what all Parliament has said.
Karan Thapar: Minister, it is not just in terms of 'need' that your critics
question the decision to have reservation for OBCs in higher education.
More importantly, they question whether reservations themselves are
efficacious and can work.
For example, a study done by the IITs themselves shows that 50 per cent of
the IIT seats for the SCs and STs remain vacant and for the remaining 50
per cent, 25 per cent are the candidates, who even after six years fail to
get their degrees. So, clearly, in their case, reservations are not
working.
Arjun Singh: I would only say that on this issue, it would not be correct
to go by all these figures that have been paraded.
Karan Thapar: You mean the IIT figures themselves could be dubious?
Arjun Singh: Not dubious, but I think that is not the last word.
Karan Thapar: All right, maybe the IIT may not be the last word, let me
then quote to you the report of the Parliamentary Committee on the welfare
for the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes - that is a Parliamentary
body.
It says that looking at the Delhi University, between 1995 and 2000, just
half the seats for under-graduates at the Scheduled Castes level and just
one-third of the seats for under-graduates at the Scheduled Tribes level
were filled. All the others went empty, unfilled. So, again, even in Delhi
University, reservations are not working.
Arjun Singh: If they are not working, it does not mean that for that reason
we don't need them. There must be some other reason why they are not
working and that can be certainly probed and examined. But to say that for
this reason, 'no reservations need to be done' is not correct.
Karan Thapar: Fifty years after the reservations were made, statistics
show, according to The Hindustan Times, that overall in India, only 16 per
cent of the places in higher education are occupied by SCs and STs. The
quota is 22.5 per cent, which means that only two-thirds of the quota is
occupied. One third is going waste, it is being denied to other people.
Arjun Singh: As I said, the kind of figures that have been brought out, in
my perception, do not reflect the realities. Realities are something much
more and of course, there is an element of prejudice also.
Karan Thapar: But these are figures that come from a Parliamentary
Committee. It can't be prejudiced; they are your own colleagues.
Arjun Singh: Parliamentary Committee has given the figures, but as to why
this has not happened, that is a different matter.
Karan Thapar: I put it to you that you don't have a case for reservations
in terms of need, you don't have a case for reservations in terms of their
efficacy, why then, are you insisting on extending them to the OBCs?
Arjun Singh: I don't want to use that word, but I think that your argument
is basically fallicious.
Karan Thapar: But it is based on all the facts available in the public
domain.
Arjun Singh: Those are facts that need to be gone into with more care. What
lies behind those facts, why this has not happened, that is also a fact.
Karan Thapar: Let's approach the issue of reservations differently in that
case. Reservations mean that a lesser-qualified candidate gets preference
over a more qualified candidate, solely because in this case, he or she
happens to be an OBC. In other words, the upper castes are being penalised
for being upper caste.
Arjun Singh: Nobody is being penalised and that is a factor that we are
trying to address. I think that the prime Minister will be talking to all
the political parties and will be putting forward a formula, which will see
that nobody is being penalised.
Karan Thapar: I want very much to talk about that formula, but before we
come to talk about how you are going to address concerns, let me point one
other corollary - Reservations also gives preference and favour to caste
over merit. Is that acceptable in a modern society?
Arjun Singh: I don't think the perceptions of modern society fit India
entirely.
Karan Thapar: You mean India is not a modern society and therefore can't
claim to be treated as one?
Arjun Singh: It is emerging as a modern society, but the parameters of a
modern society do not apply to large sections of the people in this
country.
Karan Thapar: Let me quote to you Jawaharlal Nehru, a man whom you
personally admire enormously. On the 27th of June 1961 wrote to the Chief
Ministers of the day as follows: I dislike any kind of reservations. If we
go in for any kind of reservations on communal and caste basis, we will
swamp the bright and able people and remain second rate or third rate. The
moment we encourage the second rate, we are lost. And then he adds
pointedly: This way lies not only folly, but also disaster. What do you say
to Jawaharlal Nehru today?
Arjun Singh: Jawaharlal Nehru was a great man in his own right and not only
me, but everyone in India accept his view.
Karan Thapar: But you are just about to ignore his advice.
Arjun Singh: No. Are you aware that it was Jawaharlal Nehru who introduced
the first ammendment regarding OBCs?
Karan Thapar: Yes, and I am talking about Jawaharlal Nehru in 1961, when
clearly he had changed his position, he said - I dislike any kind of
reservations.
Arjun Singh: I don't think one could take Panditji's position at any point
of time and then overlook what he had himself initiated.
Karan Thapar: Am I then to understand that regardless of the case that is
made against reservations in terms of need, regardless of the case that has
been made against reservations in terms of efficacy, regardless of the case
that has been made against reservations in terms of Jawaharlal Nehru, you
remain committed to extending reservations to the OBCs.
Arjun Singh: I said because that is the will of Parliament. And I think
that common decisions that are taken by Parliament have to be honoured.
Karan Thapar: Let me ask you a few basic questions - If reservations are
going to happen for the OBCs in higher education, what percentage of
reservations are we talking about?
Arjun Singh: No, that I can't say because that has yet to be decided.
Karan Thapar: Could it be less than 27 per cent?
Arjun Singh: I can't say anything on that, I have told you in the very
beginning that at this point of time it is not possible for me to.
Karan Thapar: Quite right. If you can't say, then that also means that the
figure has not been decided.
Arjun Singh: The figure will be decided, it has not been decided yet.
Karan Thapar: The figure has not been decided. So, therefore the figure
could be 27, but it could be less than 27 too?
Arjun Singh: I don't want to speculate on that because as I said, that is
decision, which will be taken by Parliament.
Karan Thapar: Whatever the figure, one thing is certain that when the
reservations for OBCs happen, the total quantum of reservations will go up
in percentage terms. Will you compensate by increasing the total number of
seats in colleges, universities, IITs and IIMs, so that the other students
don't feel deprived.
Arjun Singh: That is one of the suggestions that has been made and is being
seriously considered.
Karan Thapar: Does it find favour with you as a Minister for Human Resource
Development?
Arjun Singh: Whatever suggestion comes, we are committed to examine it.
Karan Thapar: You may be committed to examine it, but do you as minister
believe that that is the right way forward?
Arjun Singh: That could be one of the ways, but not the only way.
Karan Thapar: What are the other ways?
Arjun Singh: I don't know. That is for the Prime Minister and the other
ministers to decide.
Karan Thapar: One way forward would be to increase the total number of
seats.
Arjun Singh: Yes, definitely.
Karan Thapar: But the problem is that as the Times of India points out, we
are talking of an increase of perhaps as much as 53 per cent. Given the
constraints you have in terms of faculty and infrastructure, won't that
order of increase dilute the quality of education?
Arjun Singh: I would only make one humble request, don't go by The Times of
India and The Hindustan Times about faculty and infrastructure, because
they are trying to focus on an argument which they have made.
Karan Thapar: All right, I will not go by The Times of India, let me
instead go by Sukhdev Thorat, the Chairman of the UGC. He points out that
today, at higher education levels - that is all universities, IITs and IIMs
- there is already a 1.2 lakh vacancy number. 40 per cent of these are in
teaching staff, which the IIT faculty themselves point out that they have
shortages of up to 30 per cent. Given those two constraint, can you
increase the number of seats?
Arjun Singh: That can be addressed and that shortage can be taken care of.
Karan Thapar: But it can't be taken care of in one swoop, it will take
several years to do it.
Arjun Singh: I don't know whether it can be taken care of straightway or in
stages, that is a subject to be decided.
Karan Thapar: Let me ask you bluntly, if you were to agree to compensate
for reservations for OBCs by increasing the number of seats, would that
increase happen at one go, or would it be staggered over a period of
two-three or four year old process.
Arjun Singh: As I told you, it is an issue that I cannot comment upon at
this moment because that is under examination.
Karan Thapar: So, it may happen in one go and it may happen in a series of
several years.
Arjun Singh: I can't speculate on that because that is not something on
which I am free to speak on today.
Karan Thapar: Will the reservation for OBCs, whatever figure your Committee
decides on, will it happen in one go, or will it slowly be introduced in
stages?
Arjun Singh: That also I cannot say because as I told you, all these issues
are under consideration.
Karan Thapar: Which means that everything that is of germane interest to
the people concerned is at the moment 'under consideration' and the
government is not able to give any satisfaction to the students who are
deeply concerned.
Arjun Singh: That is not the point. The government knows what to do and it
will do what is needed.
Karan Thapar: But if the government knows what to do, why won't you tell me
what the government wants to do?
Arjun Singh: Because unless the decision is taken, I cannot tell you.
Karan Thapar: But you can share with me as the Minister what you are
thinking.
Arjun Singh: No.
Karan Thapar: So, in other words, we are manitaining a veil of secrecy and
the very people who are concerned...
Arjun Singh: I am not maintaining a veil of secrecy. I am only telling you
what propriety allows me to tell you.
Karan Thapar: Propriety does not allow you to share with the people who are
protesting on the streets what you are thinking?
Arjun Singh: I don't think that that can happen all the time.
Karan Thapar: But there are people who feel that their lives and their
futures are at stake and they are undertaking fasts until death.
Arjun Singh: It is being hyped up, I don't want to go into that.
Karan Thapar: Do you have no sympathy for them?
Arjun Singh: I have every sympathy.
Karan Thapar: But you say it is being hyped up.
Arjun Singh: Yes, it is hyped up.
Karan Thapar: So, then, what sympathy are you showing?
Arjun Singh: I am showing sympathy to them and not to those who are hyping
it up.
Karan Thapar: The CPM says that if the reservations for the OBCs are to
happen, then what is called the creamy layer should be excluded. How do you
react to that?
Arjun Singh: The creamy layer issue has already been taken care of by the
Supreme Court.
Karan Thapar: That was vis -a-vis jobs in employment, what about at the
university level, should they be excluded there as well because you are
suggesting that the answer is yes?
Arjun Singh: That could be possible.
Karan Thapar: It could be possible that the creamy layer is excluded from
reservations for OBCs in higher education?
Arjun Singh: It could be, but I don't know whether it would happen
actually.
Karan Thapar: Many people say that if reservations for OBCs in higher
education happen, then the children of beneficiaries should not be entitled
to claim the same benefit.
Arjun Singh: Why?
Karan Thapar: So that there is always a shrinking base and the rate doesn't
proliferate.
Arjun Singh: I don't think that that is a very logical way of looking at
it.
Karan Thapar: Is that not acceptable to you?
Arjun Singh: No, it is not the logical way of looking at it.
Karan Thapar: So, with the possible exception of the creamy layer
exclusion, reservation for OBCs in higher education will be almost
identical to the existing reservations for SC/STs?
Arjun Singh: Except for the percentage.
Karan Thapar: Except for the percentage.
Arjun Singh: Yes.
Karan Thapar: So, in every other way, they will be identical.
Arjun Singh: Yes, in every other way.
Karan Thapar: Mr Arjun Singh, on the 5th of April when you first indicated
that the Government was considering reservation for OBCs in higher
education, was the Prime Minister in agreement that this was the right
thing to do?
Arjun Singh: I think, there is a very motivated propaganda is on this
issue. Providing reservation to OBCs was in the public domain right from
December 2005, when Parliament passed the enabling resolution.
Karan Thapar: Quite true. But had the Prime Minister specifically agreed on
or before 5th of April to the idea?
Arjun Singh: Well, I am telling you it was already there. A whole Act was
made, the Constitution was amended and the Prime Minister was fully aware
of what this is going to mean. Actually, he had a meeting in which OBC
leaders were called to convince them that this would give them the desired
advantage. And they should, therefore, support this resolution. And at that
meeting, he himself talked to them. Now, how do you say that he was
unaware?
Karan Thapar: But were you at all aware that the Prime Minister might be in
agreement with what was about to happen but might not wish it disclosed
publicly at that point of time? Were you aware of that?
Arjun Singh: It was already there in public domain, that's what I am trying
to tell you.
Karan Thapar: Then answer this to me. Why are members of the PMO telling
journalists that Prime Minister was not consulted and that you jumped the
gun?
Arjun Singh: Well, I don't know which member of the PMO you are talking
about unless you name him.
Karan Thapar: Is there a conspiracy to make you the fall guy?
Arjun Singh: Well, I don't know whether there is one or there is not. But
fall guys are not made in this way. And I am only doing what was manifestly
clear to every one, was cleared by the party and the Prime Minister. There
is no question of any personal agenda.
Karan Thapar: They say that, in fact, you brought up this issue to
embarrass the Prime Minister.
Arjun Singh: Why should I embarrass the Prime Minister? I am with him. I am
part of his team.
Karan Thapar: They say that you have a lingering, forgive the word,
jealousy because Sonia Gandhi chose Manmohan Singh and not you as Prime
Minister.
Arjun Singh: Well, that is canard which is below contempt. Only that person
can say this who doesn't know what kind of respect and regard I hold for
Sonia Gandhi. She is the leader. Whatever she decides is acceptable to me.
Karan Thapar: They also say that you brought this issue up because you felt
that the Prime Minister had been eating into your portfolio. Part of it had
gone to Renuka Chaudhury and, in fact, your new deputy minister Purandar
Sridevi had taken over certain parts. This was your way of getting back.
Arjun Singh: No one was taking over any part. This is a decision which the
Prime Minister makes as to who has to have what portfolio. And he asked Mrs
Renuka Devi to take it and he cleared it with me first.
Karan Thapar: So there is no animus on your part?
Arjun Singh: Absolutely not.
Karan Thapar: They say that you did this because you resented the Prime
Minister's popular image in the country, that this was your way of
embroiling him in a dispute that will make him look not like a modern
reformer but like an old-fashioned, family-hold politician instead.
Arjun Singh: Well, the Tammany Hall political stage is over> He is our
Prime Minister and every decision he has taken is in the full consent with
his Cabinet and I don't think there can be any blame on him.
Karan Thapar: One, then, last quick question. Do you think this is an
issue, which is a sensitive issue, where everyone knew there would have
been passions and emotions that would have aroused has been handled as
effectively as it should have been?
Arjun Singh: Well, I have not done anything on it. I have not sort of what
you call jumped the gun. If this is an issue, which is sensitive, everyone
has to treat it that way.
Karan Thapar: But your conscience as HRD Minister is clear?
Arjun Singh: Absolutely clear.
Karan Thapar: There is nothing that you could have done to make it easier
for the young students?
Arjun Singh: Well, I am prepared to do anything that can be done. And it is
being attempted.
Karan Thapar: For seven weeks, they have been protesting in the hot sun. No
minister has gone there to appease them, to alley their concerns, to
express sympathy for them. Have politicians let the young people of India
down?
Arjun Singh: Well, I myself called them. They all came in this very room.
Karan Thapar: But you are the only one.
Arjun Singh: You are accusing me only. No one else is being accused.
Karan Thapar: What about the Government of India? Has the Government of
India failed to respond adequately?
Arjun Singh: From the Government of India also, the Defence Minister met
them.
Karan Thapar: Only recently.
Arjun Singh: That is something because everyone was busy with the
elections.
Karan Thapar: For seven weeks no one met them.
Arjun Singh: No, but we are very concerned. Certainly, all of us resent the
kind of force that was used. I condemned it the very first day it happened.
Karan Thapar: All right, Mr Arjun Singh. We have reached the end of this
interview. Thank you very much for speaking on the subject.
about this entry
you’re currently reading “
- published:
- 11:26 PM
- by T
0 comments (Post a Comment)